Making an informed COBRA decision

Topher Reynoso
January 21, 2024

Leaving an employer often initiates a crucial health insurance decision-making process. While COBRA is commonly known, understanding its cost implications and exploring alternatives can be intimidating. Studies reveal that individuals frequently find themselves overwhelmed and ill-prepared when faced with these decisions, highlighting the necessity of seeking guidance for personalized health insurance solutions.

Getting health insurance through your employer is a very normal experience. Great employers offer great benefits. But what we don’t often talk about is what that means when you leave an employer and how you untangle yourself from your former employer’s health plan to figure out what’s best for you moving forward.

It's not surprise that most individuals leaving their jobs feel overwhelmed when choosing health insurance post-employment. The complexities of various plans, costs, and coverage options often leave individuals feeling ill-equipped to make informed decisions without expert guidance.

According to a study by the Kaiser Family Foundation, COBRA premiums can be steep, with individuals paying the full cost of coverage plus an administrative fee. On average, COBRA premiums can reach nearly $600 per month for individual coverage and over $1,700 per month for family coverage. This cost burden often makes COBRA unaffordable for many employees transitioning from one job to the next (especially if they have a gap of a month of more between employment).

Oftentimes folks receive that multi-page COBRA document filled with legalese and don’t seek any additional guidance, they just assume the extent of their decision is to either pay the high COBRA premiums or not. However, studies published by the New York Times indicate that individuals who sought professional help when selecting health insurance plans were more likely to choose cost-effective coverage that met their needs and were less likely to switch plans the following year. Guidance from insurance professionals significantly increased the likelihood of finding better-suited plans and understanding potential cost-saving opportunities, easing the decision-making process.

Many people don’t know it but their employers have insurance brokers who help them understand plan options and find the right fit for the company. While there are insurance brokers who can help individuals do the same thing, it’s not often that people think about seeking this guidance when they’re at a crossroads between employment. However, getting guidance from someone who can review your COBRA option and actually compare it with other options that you may qualify for is the best way to ensure that you make the right choice for you and your family.

Most individuals exploring marketplace plans find them to be, on average, 20% cheaper than COBRA coverage. Moreover, Marketplace plans often provide more flexibility and diverse coverage options, including potential subsidies that significantly reduce monthly premiums, making them more financially feasible. That’s not to say that COBRA doesn’t have its advantages. There are definitely situations where COBRA will clearly be a person or family’s best option.

For example, if you are coming up on some expensive medical bills like a planned surgery and you’ve already met your annual deductible in your previous employer’s plan, COBRA may be a great option for you rather than resetting your deductible with a new health insurance option. It’s not always a simple decision, especially if you aren’t familiar with the ins and outs of the health insurance industry. You may miss things like tax subsidies or other government programs that you may qualify for which could seriously reduce your cost of coverage.

Seeking guidance from insurance professionals or consultants can alleviate decision-related stress, ensuring a more thorough understanding of available options and cost-saving opportunities. Navigating health insurance decisions post-employment isn’t merely about choosing coverage; it's about making financially sound decisions that safeguard your health and finances. COBRA might seem like the default choice, but exploring alternatives with professional guidance can lead to more cost-effective and tailored solutions.

The decision-making process can be overwhelming, but seeking expert support empowers you to make informed choices that align with your needs and financial circumstances. Remember, the right choice now can lead to substantial savings and better coverage in the long run.

Topher Reynoso
January 21, 2024
Share this post